The product people don't know they're searching for.

Strategy · 5 min read

A client came to me with an education app idea. He wanted to build a study tool for a specific trade qualification. I asked him what the competition looked like. He said there was none. No apps. No online platforms. No digital tools at all. Everything in his industry was still taught from textbooks and classroom instruction. Tens of thousands of people sit this qualification every year, and nobody had built anything for them.

So we checked the search data. Google Trends, keyword tools, App Store search volume. The numbers came back at zero. Nobody was searching for this product. And that scared him.

But zero search volume and zero demand are two completely different things.

People can't search for what they don't know exists

The reason nobody is searching for his app is simple. Nobody knows it's possible. The training material has always been textbooks. That's what people expect. They're not unhappy with the textbooks in the way that makes them go looking for alternatives. They're unhappy in a quieter way. They struggle through the material. They fail the exam. They resit it. They accept that the training is just hard. It doesn't occur to them that an app could make it easier, because no app has ever existed in that space.

This happens more often than people think. Nobody searched for "ride sharing app" before that category existed. Nobody searched for "language learning game" before someone built one. The demand was always there. People wanted easier transport and better ways to learn languages. They just didn't have a name for the solution yet.

When you're building something new in a space that's never had a digital product, the search volume will always be zero. That's not a warning sign. It's the nature of creating a new category.

Proven demand in a new format

Here's what the client did have: proof that people were paying for the existing solution. Thousands of people buying textbooks every year. Thousands enrolling in classroom courses. Thousands paying for exam preparation. The demand for the knowledge was documented and real. What didn't exist was a digital format for delivering that knowledge.

That's a fundamentally different situation from building something where no demand exists at all. If people are already spending money to learn this material, and you can deliver it in a format that's more accessible, more portable, and more effective, you're not creating demand from nothing. You're redirecting demand that already exists into a better channel.

Kim and Mauborgne studied this pattern for their Blue Ocean Strategy research. They analysed 108 business launches and found that only 14% created new market categories. But those 14% captured 61% of total profits. The biggest opportunities aren't in crowded search results where everyone is fighting for the same keywords. They're in spaces where nobody has built anything yet.

Your job is to create the category, then teach people it exists

When there's no search volume, traditional marketing doesn't work the way you'd expect. You can't run Google Ads against keywords nobody is typing. You can't optimise your App Store listing for search terms that don't exist. The launch strategy has to be different. You go directly to the people who need it. Industry forums. Training providers. Professional networks. The client knew people in his trade who would test the app and share it if it was good.

The first users aren't people who searched for your product. They're people who hear about it and think, "Why didn't this exist before?" And once those first users start talking, the search volume follows. People start googling the app name. They start searching for the category. You're not competing for an existing keyword. You're creating the keyword.

So if your app idea has zero search volume but targets a space where people are already paying for a worse version of what you want to build, don't let the empty search data scare you off. It might be the biggest signal you have. Nobody is competing for that space because nobody has built for it yet. And the first person to build something good gets to own the whole category.

Sources
Blue Ocean Strategy (Kim & Mauborgne, 2005) - Just 14% of product launches created new market categories, yet they captured 61% of total profits.

Related blog posts:

The product people don't know they need →

How to validate your app idea before spending a cent →

The App Store won't market your app for you →